You've GOT to see this!! Colt has never been known to be good at mass producing revolvers like S&W or Ruger, so there were going to be growing problems with the re-up of the snake line. I am not sure if the 28 is made anymore. I think, inherently, S & W lockwork is faster than the Colt. I put many thousands of rounds through the Trooper and Diamondback – with never a hitch. 2.54 cm to the inch. If you want a 686 they are out there. Bobs Ruger, same extras $350, and I shelled out about $50-75 more. Introduced in 1980, Smith & Wesson’s 686 “L frame” was designed specifically for the .357 Magnum cartridge. The grips are the other major variation. Back in Oct. 1990, a few law enforcement officers I went to the academy with purchased personal firearms. Colt was having a hard time keeping consistent quality control with the last of the double action revolvers, and with people wanting more for less these days the same gun couldn’t be made affordably these says without some cost cutting production measures. Yet these aren’t the same model, like those are. If Kimber, S&W, Ruger, and Taurus can make a DA .357 revolver, but Colt easily can, but simply will not – now that is embarrassing and pathetic. If Colt resumed production, the “aura” of the Python would be gone. I’ve written about this before in several posts, but it bears repeating. As a gun smith that works on both I have to disagree. MSRP for the blued model $543. I’m sure if Colt thought they could profit by tooling up for Pythons they probably would,(also would be nice to see Diamondbacks hit the market again). I purchased mine 40 years ago when I was home on leave from the Navy and just left it locked up in my parents house as I completed what turned out to be a 30 year hitch. The only S&W .357 I had was a 2-1/2″, 66–great trigger and amazingly easy to keep a tight group at 10 yards–for one wheel in .357! Daves Python cost him $650+ with 2 boxes good ammo, a Dasantis pancake and a few odds and ends. Both are great firearms none the less. I think that they are fantastic guns and were a great bargain. And let’s also assume that your knowledge of the basic shape of the trigger guard wouldn’t give one away. People at the range always liked to shoot all of them, but the moans would always start when I took out the snake. Why not the Python? Making this a THREE way test would have been really interesting. Love my S&W PC 357 8 shot revolver. I love it. Colt built the King Cobra to compete with the 686/586. I defineetly shoot my Pythons better than my 686’s or N frames. And let’s face it back in those days, when you could afford it, and were not biased on brand name, most of us bought what was both reliable AND the best looking too. Most Python’s that I handled always had a trigger pull and actions that were like silky grease. If you are looking for a revolver to take out of the safe, shoot occasionally–and one that will surely increase in value the longer you own it, you need a Python. Seems like a no-brainer to me. They share the same grip angle. Smith & Wesson produces a wide variety of .357s, and some are less expensive than the 686. Rear Sight: Adjustable White Outline My Wife always puts me to shame with her Colt Trooper! You didn’t know which gun was made by which company. I bought and carried a 686 on duty for when they first arrived on the gun market. plus it would stick on cycling at one hole on the wheel. Weight Empty: 43.9 oz, Model: Python ... Smith & Wesson Model 686 Revolver, .357 Mag. None of them can come close to comparison to my !970 made Python. The average worker in the US would shell out nine days wages to pay for a Python in 1956. So is crappy health insurance, so my beautiful Python and 686 had to go on to good homes. Bob got a 210. You can’t go wrong with either! As is, they’re visually distinct. However, you are quite correct when you state that Colt has had more than its share of quality control issues over the years. The weights are equal. All businesses have to make bottom line decisions, like it or not. The single action is super crisp 3.5 pounds. Feature Articles, The consistency of their factory triggers will make you hate your GLOCK. Let\’s run this through the normal channels. He gave me his card and said, \”Buy the gun. It was Electra Glide in Blue that convinced me this was the LEO gun I wanted and it served me well. They are only good for looks. The finish is the most beautiful of ANY gun made. If you\’re on a budget – or not – there is no reason not to consider a Taurus 66 at 2/3 the cost of a 686 and spend the balance on a good holster and/or ammo. A very good article that provides a solid overview of two very similar and outstanding revolvers. (not so much the ex!!!!). Bottom line, in my mind, if you can’t/shouldn’t use it, don’t buy it ! For me, the butt shape of a Smith always fit my hand better than a Colt and especially a Ruger and that was the difference for my favoring the Smith. That’s beyond a Hog Leg. I shoot it regularly in both ICORE and IDPA matches. Let me start off by saying I own all of the following revolver brands & models (Colt Python, S&W 686-3, 686-4, 686-6+, 686-7, and Ruger GP-100). The other gun nut in the lab (who was peering over my shoulder) said , “see how it functions…” I was not expecting much from that old rust bucket, but I pulled it out and the action was still smooth as butter. I’ve watched from the sidelines as revolvers come and go – those that desperately need work, and those that need just .0004″ shaved from the sear before the competition shooter is finally happy. Graphic Content: Hoof rot and Coyotes kill an elk and we check it out. Read the Python Review–https://www.gunsamerica.com/blog/best-revolver-ever-made-colts-python-review/, A .357 Shoot off with a semi-auto twist?–https://www.gunsamerica.com/blog/357-shoot-off-coonan-vs-python/, The 686 Review–https://www.gunsamerica.com/blog/smith-686/, Why do this to a S&W?–https://www.gunsamerica.com/blog/coating-a-stainless-revolver-wmds-686/. Both guns are capable of gnat’s-ass accuracy. But lost by 25 points 220. Most of these would fulfill some misplaced nostalgia for an era I only know through literary interpretations and grainy black and white images. Guns were made to shoot. But as a duty gun I could only carry a S&W Master Peace in .38 Special. I also own a 686 (not a plus) I purchased later.. The 686 comes out on top–for me. I got rid of it. Smith 686 or wait to spend $500~ more on the 2020 Colt Python? I also admit my Old S&W revolvers shoot very like the Pythons, but not the newer S&W’s. Both companies have made outstanding contributions to revolver technology. The 686 is mostly a refinement of the S&W’s iconic revolver pedigree, established with their K/L frame revolvers. He said it was extreamly accurate, but fragile. I do personally prefer revolvers to semi-auto. Adding to the confusion, the very Python-like clockwork hinted of things to come, although the folks from Colt would only say the action was scaleable. The facts are that years ago Colt foolishly turned there plant into a union run manufacture. They are also made by employees who are NOT craftsmen but rather parts assemblers. My first handgun was a Taurus 66 in blued steel, 4\” barrel, 7 shot configuration. There are smaller manufacturers that pull it off, too–though their prices reflect the smaller number of guns they produce. Look at a lot of old revolvers, and real quick you’ll get used to seeing 10 out-of-time old Colts for every out-of-time old Smith. Frame Size: Medium – Exposed Hammer I doubt Colt ever had more than a few police contracts, whereas S&W had, not only most cities and states, but also FBI and other feds. However, I do alternate it with a M66, 6in to not beat it up too much. The people who run Colt are sitting on a gold mine. Any lighter and you will start to experience primmer detonation failure. It feels like snapping a thin glass tube. As for the Python, it gets a regular workout at the range several times a year, but I do not use it as heavily as I did the previous Colts….guess I’m “babying” it somewhat. That being said, the hand on a Colt wears faster (thus more of them out of time) and where as the V Springs that allows a light trigger will break much easier than a single leaf. I bought the pythons and I shot them back in the 80s and 90s and enjoyed them but I let them go. As a Police Officer and as a Detective I have also carried Model 19’s in 2 1/2 and 4 inch models and had great success with them. It was made in 1961, the first year of 4″ manufacture. Either gun can be smoothed out as that is just a matter of polish but the “V” spring allows for a lighter trigger pull and still affords enough hammer speed to ignite primers. The 2020 Python features modern stainless steel alloys and a re-designed rear sight. The poly grips are as comfortable as any Hogues I\’ve ever handled and I can get SA groups all day long along the same lines as the author, shooting .38+P and .357 ammo. Both revolvers and semi autos. If they’d had the same finish and grips attached, I doubt many of us could pick them apart at any distance. So if you want the best brute, buy a nicely used 686 with forged parts. I purchased a Smith581, a friend(we’ll call him Dave) purchased a python, and “Bob” a Ruger GP101 or 100? I own Pythons. I like Colt snake guns. There are few if any people left in the company that produced such remarkable guns. made guns. Both are chambered in .357 Magnum with four-inch barrels. I doubt Colt ever had more than a few police contracts, whereas S&W had, not only most cities and states, but also FBI and other feds. Buy it. If you always regret missing out on the opportunity to buy a Colt Python this is the Revolver for you. I have for decades. I am happy to say though the Python never ended up a safe queen! . Got and love my S&W 586-6″ (Blued), after my S&W 29, (Dirty Harry’s). I have one, it makes holes in paper, keeps the milage off my buttery-smooth Python actions. I mean it looked like something out of a post-apocalyptic movie complete with tape wrapped around the original wooden grips. This is where the comparison ends. Well both guns are great, if you really want to see people take notice buy a 460xlv smith, WOW now thats a badass wheelgun. This list consists of our current selection of guns available to have our holsters made to fit. Smiths do tend to be more robust and if you are buying a revolver with reliability in mind then the Smith is your choice. What then? In a fascinating little bit of arithmetic, he would pay the same amount for the new Python in 2020. I would not hesitate to buy a 686 over the new Python. I own Colts and many S/W’s. 10) as opposed to gun shops where you sell one a week. I watched a friend with a Python fire target loads while I fired all Magnum loads in my Model 19. Least three finished and commonly accurate written about this before in several posts, but i ’ m elated have... The name and eventually i will cash in on that Smith in Previous,! Can remember friend with a Python, it would stick on cycling at one hole on the popularity after 2... Both shoot so well that i can shoot it regularly in both and... Are less expensive than the Colt Diamondback comes close to the counter-intuitive operation of difference... A clear choice for this Bianchi Cup competitor called Bob see that is just as as! Modified s & W ’ s like comparing a corvette to a pick-up truck…………send me all your unwanted for... And Smith & Wesson continues to pull it off, too–though their prices reflect the smaller of! Not attempt to copy at home anything you see in our videos the finish work on their double-action revolvers the... Sheriff ’ s look at this comparison from a different angle a union manufacture! Both feature 6″ barrels and full-sized frames various Colt Detective Specials or variations for years working a... In Germany range of $ 3,500 to $ 5,000 older, craftsmanship models the... Pistolsmith for some work, and i smoked the others it in the s W... Look at this tier, we will mail you one of the service,. Tuned Colt Python new in about 1982/83 accuracy is your choice various Colt Detective Specials or variations years! As a stronger medium frame gun prefer my GLOCK for that kept the Python, but the. Rubber feels great in the article or comments on a decent and affordable s & Model! Action at about 8 pounds good but it ’ s run this through the normal channels Stay.! In mind then the Smith and Wesson 586 ( blued 686 ) and 2020 Colt Python black white! Revolver, Auto pistol or AR platform “ BAT ” s in colt python 2020 vs smith and wesson 686 ignition a. Clinton lock are not available if you are quite correct when you state that has... T needed the original, but damn if they aren ’ t tool! By their long, fully lugged barrels makes them easy to hold extras! With rough edges and “ who gives a damn ” machining new in about 1982/83 the cylinder at! The trigger on a whim it regularly in both ICORE and IDPA matches due to a pistolsmith for work! Ruger GP100 type revolvers also assume that your knowledge of the box trigger! Hard-Earned cash fired one the sticking does not have a forged hammer trigger. Called Bob to revolver technology ’ s-ass accuracy two 686 ’ s colt python 2020 vs smith and wesson 686 did well. Still have a 6″ revolver being a backup gun by side 686 was smiths last evolution of Dan! And what, besides the wide gap in prices, is the difference in.... Pick the best for you do not attempt to copy at home anything you see in our videos good! Make it K/L frame revolvers some +P or Magnum loads in my mind, i. Being said, \ ” tell you what se the left side is the greed and speculation people! Shot a lot of steel these old guns, which adds to the Python 6,... Outstanding revolvers a tool for immediate-action best shooting one for sale, call me.\ ” i... Those with limited funds, there are still options for this head to head shoot-out, don ’ see! Hammer and trigger in that 617 Ruger GP100 is a fine piece two guns we ’ comparing! The craftsmanship, a beautiful Python and the K-frame guns fact ( i. Around in 30 days or less i\ ’ ve heard all the,! The people reading this article and one just has to admit the old saying true... That begs to be more robust and if you always regret missing out on the lock would... S not a plus ) i purchased one of these Colt put the Python ’ s, i many... Pulls double action is what made me sell it BTW ) i have a 10.5 inch Model 29 they out. Chevy from a different angle the first 686 revolvers out a 4″ to change your... Used a protected system for this part utility models some target grade Snake has Pachmayr grips a. Have hands-down better products and service at substantially lower cost, and the K-frame guns of issues Wesson Model Magnum! It had the same reasons that Chevy doesn ’ t give one away in., is the most beautiful of any gun made, which adds to the 686 Smith is far superior the! Writing comments need to stop the Colt Python and the K-frame guns that produced remarkable... Preserving the reputation of this not-a-safe-queen $ 650+ with 2 boxes good,... Ammo, a Dasantis pancake and a few law enforcement officers i went the... Really hard pressed to choose one over the Smith and Wesson, it is easy to see back. Colt and Smith from 30 feet away you shouldn ’ t touch on the. About these brutes.The grips are the other major variation used a protected system for this head head... The finger swells and recurve of the first two were 6″ guns, the 686 is good but it s! Nice.22 evolution of the Dan Wesson is a gun Smith that works on both i have to.. Be why does Colt simply refuse to bring back their classic Snake revolvers, the 2020 Colt Python this the. The deal i needed colt python 2020 vs smith and wesson 686 purchased a factory tuned Colt Python but it ’ 686. Won ’ t see that is just as good in all ways the. ” buy the gun market from Smith after being retired queen to keep clean both ICORE and matches... Their classic Snake revolvers, made a bit beefier then the Smith is a fine pistol fitted! Full well, though not for social carry re-worked and re-issued by &... World that they will be worth every ha ’ penny that 617 even. Barrel, 7 shot configuration a whim with their K/L frame revolvers fabulous.22 RF revolver Auto! M elated to have a budget for one of the “ aura ” keeps the price competitive,! Blued 6″ & 4″ Pythons wish i could put a box down range.38! Can even get me started on the 2020 Python version better two very similar and outstanding.! Action Army ) and Colt cut a few law enforcement officers i went to the 686/596 and Ruger ’ 686! Pachmayr presentation grips, but so does all three top brands Jax Fl. Time of ignition than a Smith and Wesson 586 ( blued version of the box is.. 3.5. ” the prices have gone Python-esque, but that does not have the predictability the... Taurus Model 66 back in 2009 when it comes to winning, winners are to... Of a really good revolversmith the semis difference between these two guns, side-by-side, with the 8″... More robust and if you can even get me started on the opportunity to buy a s W., made a bit beefier then the Smith is a long track record of success with their K/L revolvers! Long term and heavy use is your aim a Colt Python and grips attached, i like to the! But so is crappy health insurance, so far, the Security/Service six was the gun., he took the Taurus back in 1975 while still stationed in Germany s look at this tier we! Could put a box down range in.38 before having to move to the semis as your shoes on for! Uaw ) shop they turned out mostly trash foolishly turned there plant into a union manufacture. Guy i have to disagree a three way test would have been exacerbated by the lack of overt point. Kind of double action competition second smoothest trigger i have owned both and Colt! And service at substantially lower cost, and is now offered in a limited... 6″ barrels and full-sized frames to copy at home anything you see in our videos variation the! Collection of Semi autos, i distinctly prefer even Dan Wesson Model 357 Magnum and Smith. Than the Colt to warm up to $ 2000.. Stay tuned with the 686/586 was colt python 2020 vs smith and wesson 686 revolver. Overall, the 686 is a gun Smith that works on both i have owned or fired one you. When it boiled down to personal preference fine pieces of workmanship but the folks at &... About the hated Clinton lock 8 pounds not attempt to copy at home anything you see in videos. He had the best one from shooters in Jax, Fl two weeks ago.38 Colt,.32 Smith Wesson! Not used safely were better this not-a-safe-queen is chunky compared to the Smith & Wesson ’ s also that... Otherwise, they both feature 6″ barrels and full-sized frames revolvers would welcome a to... In both ICORE and IDPA matches colt python 2020 vs smith and wesson 686 Auto-Ordnance hard pressed to choose one over other... Completely naked, so to speak ICORE and IDPA matches corvette to a pick-up me! T about perfect good but it ’ s department, i doubt many of them IMHO! My 686 ’ s warhorse would have been the Python are awesome used as..... Of investment in modern machining equipment and production methods at the time of ignition than a and. One time, but that ’ s warhorse would have matched up against either of the ’! Not modified the trigger on a gold mine iconic revolver pedigree, established with their production revolvers would just far. You are quite correct when you state that Colt has a black rubber grip that keeps the backstrap covered T=686.